Выпуск
Bored or Broken? How to Know When to Change Your Ads
Advertising in America · 27 августа 2026 г. · 40 мин
You're sick of your ads. Your audience hasn't seen them yet. That is the entire problem, and it's costing businesses millions in prematurely abandoned campaigns, reset brand signals, and marketing energy aimed at the wrong target entirely. In this episode of Advertising in America, Mick Torbay and Chris Torbay take different doors to the same room. Mick's argument: your good ads need to run longer than you're comfortable with. Chris's argument: the individual ads should stay fresh, but the advertising idea underneath them should never change. Both are right. And the distinction between the two is what separates businesses that build real brand equity from businesses that keep starting from zero. The conversation goes deep into why the client is always sick of the ad before the audience has registered it once, what peer-reviewed wear-out research actually says about how long ads stay effective, why the new marketing hire who needs to "make their mark" is the single biggest threat to any great campaign, and how to tell the difference between a campaign that's bored and one that's actually broken. Mick plays a mortgage broker's "perfect" radio ad. The man ran it unchanged for twenty years. You'll know within three seconds why that was a crime against attention. If you've ever been tempted to kill a campaign that was working, or suspect someone on your team is doing it for the wrong reasons, this episode is the intervention you didn't know you needed. Episode Highlights: Your Audience Hasn't Started Counting Yet: Why the client's clock and the customer's clock are never synchronized and what happens when you act on the wrong one. The Science of Wear-Out: What peer-reviewed research from the Journal of Advertising Research actually says about emotional ads vs. rational ones, and which outlasts which by a significant margin. Ads vs. Advertising: The distinction between the episode and the show. Mac vs. PC ran 66 individual spots. The advertising never changed. The CMO Tenure Trap: Average CMO tenure is 4 to 4.5 years. Great campaigns take 5 to 7 years to compound. The runways don't match, and the industry pays for it. Bored or Broken?: One question to ask before you change anything, and what to do depending on the answer. Famous Campaigns Don't Die of Natural Causes: From Skittles to Nike to Allstate's Mayhem, why the brands we still talk about stayed the course while everyone else chased novelty. The New Marketing Hire Problem: Why the fastest, easiest, most visible win for a new CMO is to kill the campaign that was just starting to build real equity. The Mona Lisa Test: The Louvre didn't change the exhibit because the security guards were bored. 🎧 Hit play if you've ever been tempted to kill a campaign that was working or suspected someone on your team was doing it for the wrong reasons. 👉 Is your campaign bored... or broken? That's the only question that matters before you change a single word. Take the Next Step: Tired of marketing that doesn't move the needle? Need to break through all the noise? In this exclusive one-on-one consultation, Wizard Ryan Chute will help you uncover: Overlooked advertising opportunities hiding in plain sight. Timeless psychological tactics that drive sales no matter the decade. Edgy strategies that capture attention and convert in today’s crowded landscape. 📞 Spots Are Limited — Reserve Yours Now! 🌐 Learn more: advertisinginamerica.com Connect with Us: https://www.youtube.com/@advertisinginamerica <a href='https://www.facebook.com/