Выпуск
Did OpenAI Steal a Math Breakthrough?
AsianDadEnergy's Podcast · 26 сентября 2026 г. · 8 мин
A few weeks ago, I saw a headline that made me stop scrolling: OpenAI had apparently solved the Navier-Stokes problem. This is a big deal. The Navier-Stokes equations describe how fluids move: water, air, blood, ocean currents, airflow around airplanes, and much more. One of the great unsolved questions is whether these equations can ever produce a mathematical singularity, where a smooth flowing fluid suddenly develops an infinitely violent whirlpool in a finite amount of time. It’s been an open problem for generations. Then OpenAI apparently threw an absolutely ridiculous amount of compute at it. According to OpenAI, its frontier model used thousands of agents, ran for roughly 88 hours, and consumed hundreds of billions of compute tokens while exploring enormous numbers of possible approaches. Basically: What happens if you throw an AI army at a problem humans have been unable to solve? The answer, apparently, was controversial. Things Got Weird Mathematicians Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpoge had been working on a related subclass of the problem for more than a year. They had also used OpenAI models to assist with their research. Right before OpenAI announced its result, Buckmaster made several serious allegations about the company’s interactions with him and about the similarity between OpenAI’s approach and their own research. He also raised questions about whether OpenAI’s models had access to his private research sessions. And he alleged that he was threatened with professional ruin if he went public. These are serious allegations, and they’re allegations, not established facts. But they raise a fascinating question: What happens to science when AI companies can throw millions of dollars of compute at a research direction discovered by an individual scientist? Then the Proof Got Challenged Things got even more interesting when mathematician Stan Palesk challenged OpenAI’s result. His argument, in extremely simplified terms, questioned whether the proposed fluid behavior could actually occur given the way energy dissipates within the system. In other words, OpenAI’s supposed mathematical singularity may have a rather large mathematical problem. I’m not a mathematician, so I’m not going to pretend I can determine which proof is correct. But that’s almost beside the point. The bigger story is what this says about AI and scientific research. The New Scientific Arms Race For hundreds of years, scientific progress has relied heavily on collaboration. Researchers publish ideas. Other researchers build on them. People share partial results. But imagine spending a year developing a promising mathematical approach, sharing it, and then watching an AI company unleash 10,000 agents and millions of dollars of compute against that exact research direction. Why would researchers openly share their work? That’s the part that worries me. AI could dramatically accelerate scientific discovery. But if revealing a promising idea simply gives enormous AI labs a roadmap to reproduce it, researchers may become much more secretive. And that could undermine one of the things that makes science work in the first place: collaboration. The irony is pretty incredible. AI might become the greatest tool for scientific discovery we’ve ever created. And it might simultaneously give scientists a reason to stop sharing their discoveries. Maybe OpenAI really did solve Navier-Stokes. Maybe it didn’t. But either way, we’re entering a world where compute itself is becoming a scientific superpower. And I have a feeling we’re going to be having a lot more arguments about who gets to use it, who gets credit,